Migrating from Apple Aperture to Google Photos

In the middle of 2014, Apple announced they were ceasing further development of Aperture, the company’s professional photo management application I had been using to catalog and post-process my images since 2005.

Aperture continued to work in OS X 10.10 Yosemite, and it works more or less under OS X 10.11 El Capitan. All bets are off for OS X 10.12, so I have finally decided to take stock of my options for migrating away from Aperture. I had compiled quite a library of tagged, annotated, and organized images since I started taking digital photographs in 1999 with an Agfa ePhoto 1680, a 1.3 megapixel camera with a swivel lens).

I use iCloud Photo Library, and the majority of images there are from my iPhone camera. I have over 174,000 images in my Aperture Library totaling 1.68TB in size and only a handful of those photos have made it into my iCloud Photo Library. Apple doesn’t offer a storage tier greater than 1TB (I have the 200GB plan), but I don’t think I would sign up even if they did. As much as I like the idea of having all of my images in Photos and accessible from all of my devices, I am concerned about the performance hit of such a large library.

Exporting over 174,000 photos from Aperture took three days.

Last week, I exported all of the images in Aperture to JPEG files, a process that took three days. Last year, I purchased my 2015 Retina 15″ MacBook Pro without the discrete graphics chips expressly because I have had two laptops crap out due to overheating chipsets. The fans were on 24/7 for the entire export time, and the battery was actually discharging very slowly even though the computer was plugged into power. Knock on wood, but I hope I didn’t cause my laptop’s motherboard any permanent harm!

A little over one hundred thousand images remaining to upload.

Right now, I am uploading all of my images to Google Photos. The service offers unlimited storage if the images are downsized to 16MP. That’s a fair tradeoff for me, since I already keep multiple offsite backups of my RAW images. I am also very interested in the automatic tagging of photos, animated GIFs and panoramas that Google Photos offers. I have spent probably months manually adding metadata to my images; I am ready for a machine to do the job for me now. Yes, there are privacy concerns about giving Google access to my photos, but as with the megapixel limit, I am at peace with the tradeoff at the moment.

I did not get around to making each RAW image perfect before exporting a high-resolution JPEG in Aperture; that would have taken forever. I figure if I come across a photo in Google Photos that needs adjusting, I could edit it in Google Photos itself or open the original in Aperture (if it’s still working, otherwise Adobe Lightroom or Photoshop), dicker with it, and re-upload it to Google.

I did consider other options before choosing Google Photos, such as SmugMug and Upthere. While the megapixel limit is higher in SmugMug, there is a 5,000 images per gallery limit; I didn’t want to spend the time right now to upload my photos in 5,000 file chunks. I have some friends who work at Upthere, but I haven’t found the time to use the product. Upthere is also a startup in a space where there’s been much consolidation, and I can’t speak to its long-term prospects. While Google’s track record with new products hasn’t been the best, I don’t think Google Photos will go the way of Google Wave or Picasa; I feel reasonably confident that it will be around in some form or another for the next decade.

As far processing and organizing my RAW files moving forward, I am still looking at DAM and RAW processing products. There’s Lightroom, but I have never warmed up to its file organization system. I used to use Capture One, but I am hesitant to plunk down a few hundred dollars and have to upgrade every few years (something I’d have to do with Lightroom too). Knowing me, I’ll probably continue to poke along with Aperture until the software finally dies or until I buy a camera that Aperture doesn’t support. My Canon EOS 5D Mark II is almost 8 years ago, but it still gets the job done. That’s one piece of technology that has lasted the test of time thus far!

10 thoughts on “Migrating from Apple Aperture to Google Photos

  1. So Aperture stored your photos in a proprietary format? That’s a lot of photos you must have needed to export if it took three days!

    Hope Google Photos works out for you and that it does stick around in one form or another for awhile. Coincidentally, a couple days ago Google announced discontinuation of their support for Picasa. This potentially affects me since I have used Picasa desktop software for the last 12 years or so for managing and post-processing my photos. I may start looking for something else that is more touch friendly and supported. At least I’ve been using OneDrive instead of Picasa Web for photo storage so no change needed there.

    1. I shoot in RAW, so Aperture had to post-process and export the images to JPEG.

      1. Carl Follstad

        Adam — reviewing posts on this thread. You posted this 4+ years ago. May I asked if you’ve changed your mind on using Google Photos? I face a similar challenge now that you did in early 2016 and am curious if you’ve revise your decision due to lessons learned or new tools available since then? Thanks.

      2. Still using Google Photos for my photos. It syncs files from my Photos hard drive for those that I take with my DSLR and the Google sync app transfers images from my iCloud Photos Library. Google Photos is still the best for searching files. I also use Amazon Prime Photos to store originals of my DSLR RAW files (no storage limits for Prime customers). You may want to read this article for additional details: https://tow.com/2016/12/31/wireless-photography-canon-5d4/ I am also on the 1TB plan with iCloud (something that added after I wrote the original article).

  2. H.world

    Aperture is discontinued but it still one of the best photo editors out there. It’s simple to use, I like it more than Photoshop element. I recently downloaded free Nik Collection plug-ins from google, it automatically added and be part of my Aperture. With Nik in Aperture, I can do anything like I would in photoshop but many time quicker and easier.

  3. You should check out Luminar. It doesn’t have asset management – YET – but it is coming to the 2018 version later this year.

  4. Hi, Adam. Thanks so much for your great sharing. I’m in the process of migrating my Aperture library too to Google Photos, having decided to simplify with migrating from Apple OS (iMac 2012) to Chromebox. My Aperture library is 580GB (over 70,000 photos), and I’ve been sync(ing) them to Google Drive with setting of moving photos to Google Photos folder, and I chose Original quality. The process has been ongoing for a couple weeks and I only got some 32GB uploaded so far. I wonder what’s happening and would appreciate it greatly if you can shed some light with your experience.
    1. what’d be expecting in the final total size of my 70k photos, I mean from an Aperture Library of some 580GB?
    2. with the option in Google Drive clicked with auto putting photos to Google Photos, do I still need to convert/export all my photos in Aperture to .jpg FIRST? Would Google Drive automatically extract my photos from Aperture library and put them in Jpg?
    3. what format (jpg ??) is Google photos using to save the photos?
    4. I found that Google photos is having a lot of ‘faces’ which I presume it gathered from the Aperture library, how to I set to prevent this happening in Google photos?
    Many thanks for your kind help and advice.

    1. Calvin I wonder if you ever found the solution. I am having the same questions. Eric

  5. Wendy

    Hi All…THANK YOU for sharing in such detail. I’m just about to embark on moving my Aperture Library so that I can update my computer to Catalina. However, I’m curious about the following…

    1. Did your organizational structure (Aperture Projects) remain in place via it’s hierarchy when migrating to Google Photos?
    2. Was there anything to help identify duplicates during import?
    3. I see that free unlimited storage is available for images that are less than 16MP, however, what about VIDEO? Did any of you upload any specific movie extensions?

    Lastly, My current photos library is redundant in google photos…I’m actually not sure what happens if I post in google photos directly…will it post a duplicate back down to my Apple Photos Library?

    THANK YOU for any feedback you are able to provide…and a prayer or two, this feels really daunting!

    1. It’s been nearly 5 years since I’ve completed this migration, so I’ll try to answer your questions as best as I can:

      1. Organizational structure DID NOT transfer over to Google, but that’s because I chose to export all photos instead of exporting individual albums. If you did the latter, you could upload them into individual albums you create in Google Photos.

      2. My files all have unique filenames (capture time), so I didn’t really have a problem with duplicate photos.

      3. Google Photos unlimited storage does not cover video, so I didn’t upload those. I didn’t take many video files to begin with, on the other hand. You’ll probably want to make sure those videos are redundantly backed up to multiple hard drives or other cloud based storage providers.

      How are you getting your Google Photos to go into your Apple Photos Library? My current sync process is the other way around. Google Photos syncs from my Apple Photos library.

      I’ve been using Lightroom as my DAM, but I have been testing out the new Photo Mechanic Plus from Camera Bits, which might be something more to my liking.

      Good luck!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: